The Bonus HtH Attacks Perk counts all Hand-to-Hand attacks. I like them Unarmed also has the very slight advantage of your character not fiddling about putting his weapon away then taking it out again every time you use an object. Some have serious armour piercing levels and huge bonuses to crit chance but cost a lot of AP. Unarmed also gives you access to a bunch of special 'bare fists only' attacks.

On the other hand, the Mega Power Fist doesn't and it also has an intrinsic armour piercing effect. Super Sledge has Knockback, which is a pain for a pure meleer as you have to run back in to range. I'd suggest Unarmed in the unmodded version. The description doesnt say it modifies the chance to crit so im guessing it penalizes your rolls on the critical hit table, which makes it absolutely worthless. Also you look nice with a super sledge - i imagine staring at your character without him holding something imposingly intimidating gets quite boring.ДЄnyway i just wanna hear your opinions on the matter and which of the 2 skills you prefer for a melee-er.ДЄs a sidequestion, i never understood what the heavy handed trait's negative side does. Melee weapons are superior at start, but no self respecting player thinks short-term. The latter is enforced by the convenience of one hander trait becoming quite useful and the bonus HtH Evade perk being a nice bonus. So now cant decide between super sledge or mega power fist styles. Although i know i will largely be annoyed by having to run towards the opponents who keep sliding gazilion hexes away after a blow, i suppose being a barbarian will have its merits in some way. ( i never played fot in anything else than CTB) But fallout 2 may prove a different matter. Naturally in FoT this idea cannot be employed for the sheer impossibility of actually beating a Behemoth silly with fists, as well as the super mutants with various burst weapons presenting a problem. Having played all fallouts so many times, i stopped trying to keep count, i realized that i should play a melee goon for the heck of it.

Fallout 2 unarmed weapons